Well, I finally did it. I’ve just bought 6,000GB of Western Digital Hard drives, a massive case and am finally planning to set up my fairly massive RAID!
I’ve spent a lot of time weighing up whether to spend (literally) hundreds of pounds on a Hardware RAID with all the nice nobbly bits, or to use Software RAID, what type of RAID to use, how to get all the hardware in there, whether its possible to extend a RAID easily without losing data, it’s been one hell of a battle.
Along with help from my friends Rich and Thom, who have a slightly better system than what I’ve got an are using hardware, I’ve learnt a hell of a lot. There was also a very useful Slashdot post, Grishankh (216268) gave some excellent advice and I’d really like to thank him for it.
So what have I learnt about hardware and software RAID?
- RAID IS NOT A BACKUP!
- Hardware RAID is incredible expensive. If you need two PCI-E cards the same, you’ll want identical cards too.
- Most hardware RAID cards are actually fake, and use software RAID. Expect to pay through the nose.
- SMART monitoring on a hardware RAID is fraught with problems. Only some cards can tell you the SMART info.
- Some hardware RAID cards use proprietary methods to store data, if you card dies and you can’t get another one, you’re possibly screwed.
- Drives must must MUST be the same size, and preferably the same format to work best.
- RAID 0 is just for spanning disks, RAID 1 is great but a tad excessive. RAID 5 seems a good, happy medium. If one drive dies, you’ll be fine, but you’ll probably lose data if more than one goes. But you really should have a backup anyway.
- If you want to extend a drive, you’ll probably have to use a software RAID app like LVM on top anyway, so any benefits of using hardware is kinda lost.
That’s why I’m using software RAID. It’s only a file server, it’s not for anything mission-critical, I’d just like to have a big drive, and a massive back up of it, so I’m planning to set up two software RAIDs in the end, one on Linux, one on Windows. At the moment, I’m just going to be backing up anything important.
In terms of configuration; I’m no expert at this, but it looks like I’m to use:
- IDE drive as bootup, and another as my (temporary) personal backup
- 6x 1TB Western Digital drives connected under RAID 5 using
- to be honest, unless anyone else has any better ideas, I’ll probably stick with the Gentoo Guide as to setting up RAID.
So what about the hardware? Ok, well obviously I’ve gone for:
Cost a lot less than hardware RAID and should get me set up quite nicely! If anyone has any advice though, I’d love to hear it!
Thanks to all those who helped me =D